Skip to content
  • Official
  • Beginner
  • English
  • 11 steps · 2 quizzes

Active Learning Strategies: A Workshop for University Lecturers

Active learning workshop for faculty: think-pair-share, peer instruction and minute papers in a 200-seat hall, the evidence charted, and a session you plan.

  • Free
  • No account needed
  • Stop any time, pick up where you left off
Workshopy.io

WorkshopyOfficial

78 lessons · used by 2 teachers

For teachers

Teaching this? Run it live with your class.

  • Students join with a code — no accounts
  • See who’s done and who’s stuck, step by step
  • It’s your copy — change anything before class

Sign in to copy it to your workspace. It’s free.

Your path

11 steps · 2 quizzes · open any step, or read it here

  1. Active learning workshop for faculty: what changes in a lectureStart hereThis active learning workshop for faculty shows university lecturers how to get every student in a large hall thinking, not only listening.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    This active learning workshop for faculty shows university lecturers how to get every student in a large hall thinking, not only listening. You practise think-pair-share, peer instruction with ConcepTests, retrieval practice, the minute paper and jigsaw, and you plan a 50-minute session that uses them.

    Active learning means students do something with an idea during class: answer, explain, compare, decide. It does not mean throwing out the lecture. Most of the strategies here take two to eight minutes and fit between the slides you already have.

    Try it: this is a peer-instruction vote in a 200-seat hall. Two hundred students have answered a conceptual question on their own. Press Talk to a neighbour, then Vote again, and watch the room change its mind.

    Interactive · A ConcepTest in a 200-seat hall: vote, talk, vote again — try it in the lesson

    In this workshop you'll:

    • see what the research says about lecturing alone, with the numbers from the papers;
    • run think-pair-share, peer instruction and jigsaw in a hall of 200;
    • use retrieval openers and the minute paper to find out what students understood;
    • answer the objections students and colleagues raise, and plan a 50-minute session.

    It takes about 75 minutes. Bring one lecture you teach: you will plan a session for it at the end.

    Takeaway: active learning is a few minutes at a time of students doing something with the idea, inside the lecture you already give.

  2. The evidence: what lecturing alone costsFaculty ask for evidence before they change how they teach, and they are right to. Three studies come up in almost every discussion of active learning. Each one is in the chart below, with the numbers exactly as the paper reports them.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    Faculty ask for evidence before they change how they teach, and they are right to. Three studies come up in almost every discussion of active learning. Each one is in the chart below, with the numbers exactly as the paper reports them.

    • Freeman and colleagues (2014, PNAS) pooled 225 studies of undergraduate science, engineering and maths courses that compared traditional lecturing with active learning. Exam and concept-inventory scores rose by 0.47 standard deviations under active learning, about 6% on an average exam. Students in lecture-only classes were 1.5 times more likely to fail: average failure rates were 33.8% with lecturing and 21.8% with active learning. The effect held in classes of every size, though it was largest in classes of 50 or fewer.
    • Crouch and Mazur (2001, American Journal of Physics) report ten years of peer instruction in Harvard's introductory physics. On the Force Concept Inventory, the course's normalised gain was 0.25 in 1990, the last year it was lectured, 0.49 in 1991, the first year with peer instruction, and rose to 0.74 by 1997 as the method was refined.
    • Roediger and Karpicke (2006, Psychological Science) had students read a prose passage, then either reread it or take a recall test. Five minutes later the rereaders recalled more (81% against 75%). A week later the tested group recalled 56% and the rereaders 42%.

    Try it: switch between the three studies. For each, say in one sentence what a lecturer should take from it.

    Interactive · The evidence for active learning, from three studies — try it in the lesson

    Two things the evidence does not say. The claim that attention collapses after ten to fifteen minutes is widely repeated, but a review of the studies behind it (Wilson and Korn, 2007, Teaching of Psychology) found little solid support for any fixed limit. And the "learning pyramid", which says people remember 10% of what they read and 90% of what they teach, has no study behind its percentages: it is a myth, and quoting it to colleagues costs you their trust. The case for active learning stands on the studies above.

    Another lesson in the library, The Science of Learning, goes deeper into retrieval and spacing. Here we use them in a large hall.

    Takeaway: across 225 studies, lecture-only courses failed more students; the gain comes from students working on the ideas, not from any fixed attention span.

  3. Think-pair-share in a 200-seat hallThink-pair-share is the smallest active-learning move there is, and it works in any room.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    Think-pair-share is the smallest active-learning move there is, and it works in any room. You ask a question, give everyone a minute to think and write an answer on their own, have them compare with the person beside them, then call on a few pairs to share with the hall.

    Each part does a different job. Think gives every student an answer of their own before anyone speaks, so the fastest voice doesn't decide for the room. Pair gets every student to put the idea into words, which is where gaps show up. Share lets you hear what the room thinks, from a few pairs rather than the two students who always answer.

    What makes a good question for it: one with more than one reasonable answer, or one where the reasoning matters more than the result. "Which of these two policies would reduce unemployment faster, and why?" works. "What is the formula for variance?" does not: there is nothing to discuss.

    Try it: first press Ask the room and see how many students take part. Then run Think, Pair and Share and compare the counters.

    Interactive · Ask the room, or think-pair-share: who takes part — try it in the lesson

    Three habits make it work in a big hall:

    1. Put the question and the time on the slide, and keep it there: "1 min alone, 2 min with your neighbour".
    2. Ask for something written in the think time (a sentence, a number, a sketch), so the minute isn't spent waiting.
    3. Call on pairs, not volunteers, and say so before they talk: "I'll ask three pairs what they decided". Students who know they may be asked prepare an answer.

    Takeaway: asking the room hears the same three hands; think-pair-share gets all 200 students to say an answer and lets you sample the room.

  4. Peer instruction: ConcepTests and the 35–70% rulePeer instruction, developed by Eric Mazur for large Harvard physics lectures, turns a lecture into a chain of short presentations, each followed by a conceptual multiple-choice question called a ConcepTest.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    Peer instruction, developed by Eric Mazur for large Harvard physics lectures, turns a lecture into a chain of short presentations, each followed by a conceptual multiple-choice question called a ConcepTest. As Crouch and Mazur (2001) describe it:

    1. Students get one or two minutes to answer on their own and report their answer (clickers, a phone poll, or coloured cards held up).
    2. Students discuss with the people around them, trying to convince each other, for two to four minutes while you walk the room and listen.
    3. They vote again. You explain the answer and move on.

    The first vote tells you what to do next. Across a semester of ConcepTests, Crouch and Mazur found that discussion raised the share of right answers substantially as long as 35% to 70% of students were right on the first vote, with the biggest gain at about 50%. Below that range too few students hold the idea to pass it on; above it most of the room already has it.

    A good ConcepTest asks about a concept, not a calculation, and its wrong options are the mistakes students really make. You find those in last year's exam scripts and office hours.

    Try it: move the slider to the share of the room that was right on the first vote, and read what to do next.

    Interactive · Read the first vote: what to do next — try it in the lesson

    You don't need clickers. Coloured cards (A to D on four colours, printed once and kept in the hall) or a free phone poll work, and fingers held up against the chest are enough for a quick read. What you need is the individual vote before the talk: without it, the confident students set the answer and the others agree.

    Takeaway: vote alone, discuss, vote again — and let the first vote decide whether you discuss, reteach or move on.

  5. Read the vote: move on, discuss or reteachIn a real lecture you get the first vote and about five seconds to decide. This step is practice at that decision, with five votes from large first-year courses.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    In a real lecture you get the first vote and about five seconds to decide. This step is practice at that decision, with five votes from large first-year courses.

    For each vote, look at the share who chose the right answer (marked) and how the wrong answers are spread. Then choose what you do next. A vote split between two options is worth a second look: it usually means two ideas are competing in the room, which is exactly what a discussion settles.

    Try it: decide all five votes. If you are unsure, open the hint.

    Interactive · Five first votes: decide what to do next — try it in the lesson

    Two things to watch for when you run this for real. Don't show the live histogram during the first vote: students drift toward the leading answer. And show it, if you show it at all, only after the second vote, when it becomes a picture of what the discussion did.

    Takeaway: the share who were right on the first vote, and where the wrong answers sit, tell you whether to discuss, reteach or move on.

  6. Check: the evidence, think-pair-share and peer instructionFour questions on the first half. Answer on your own first, as your students would.Quiz · 4 questions
    Read the questions

    Four questions on the first half. Answer on your own first, as your students would.

    Question 1. In Freeman and colleagues' 2014 meta-analysis, how did failure rates compare?

    • About the same under lecturing and active learning
    • About 34% under traditional lecturing and about 22% under active learning
    • Active learning helped only in classes of under 50 students
    • Lecturing had lower failure rates, but lower exam scores

    Question 2. Why does think-pair-share start with time to think alone?

    • It gives you time to set up the next slide
    • Every student commits to an answer before the fastest voice decides for the room
    • Students learn more in silence than in conversation
    • It replaces the need for a share-out

    Question 3. On a ConcepTest, 52% of the hall chose the right answer on the first vote. What do you do?

    • Explain the answer and move on
    • Reteach the idea from the start
    • Have students convince their neighbours, then vote again
    • Show the histogram and ask the majority to explain

    Question 4. A colleague quotes "students remember 10% of what they read and 90% of what they teach". What is the best reply?

    • It is right, and it proves that lectures don't work
    • Those percentages have no study behind them; the case for active learning rests on studies like Freeman 2014
    • It is true only for STEM subjects
    • The real figures are 20% and 80%
  7. Retrieval practice: a low-stakes opener for every lectureRetrieval practice is asking students to bring an idea back from memory instead of reading it again. Roediger and Karpicke's experiment, in the chart two steps back, is one of many: being tested on material made it stick better a week later than rereading it.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    Retrieval practice is asking students to bring an idea back from memory instead of reading it again. Roediger and Karpicke's experiment, in the chart two steps back, is one of many: being tested on material made it stick better a week later than rereading it. In a lecture, the cheapest way to use this is to open with three short questions, answered on paper or in a poll, before you start anything new.

    Three choices make an opener work:

    • Mix the past in. One question from last lecture, and one from two or more weeks ago. Coming back to older material spreads the practice out, which helps it last.
    • Ask students to use an idea, not only to name it. "What is the standard error?" checks a definition; "A sample of 100 has a standard deviation of 20: what is the standard error?" checks that they can use it.
    • Keep it ungraded. The point is practice, and the answers tell you what to revisit. Marks turn it into a test, and students start looking up the answers.

    Try it: you teach a first-year statistics course of 220 students. Build today's opener from the question bank.

    Interactive · Build a three-question retrieval opener — try it in the lesson

    In a 200-seat hall, the opener has a second job: it settles the room. Put the questions on the screen as students arrive, start the clock at the hour, and take the answers by poll or a show of cards. Spend one minute on the question most of them missed.

    Takeaway: open with three ungraded questions from memory, old and new, and let the answers tell you what to revisit.

  8. The minute paper and the muddiest pointThe minute paper and the muddiest point are two of the classroom assessment techniques Angelo and Cross collected in Classroom Assessment Techniques (1993).InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    The minute paper and the muddiest point are two of the classroom assessment techniques Angelo and Cross collected in Classroom Assessment Techniques (1993). In the last two or three minutes of a lecture, students answer one or two questions on a slip of paper or a phone form:

    • Minute paper: "What was the most important thing you learned today?" and "What question do you still have?"
    • Muddiest point: "What was the least clear part of today's lecture?"

    They take two minutes of class time and give you something no exam does: what the room found hard, while you can still fix it. The work is in reading them. With 200 slips you don't answer each one; you sort them into a few themes, count, and open the next lecture with the biggest one.

    Try it: twelve muddiest-point responses from a statistics lecture on sampling. Put each in its theme, then decide what the next lecture opens with.

    Interactive · Sort twelve muddiest-point responses into themes — try it in the lesson

    Closing the loop is what makes students keep writing honest answers. Start the next lecture by naming what the slips said ("Forty of you asked about…"), and answer it. With a phone form, the slips arrive sorted by time and you can read a few hundred in fifteen minutes.

    Takeaway: two minutes at the end of a lecture tells you what the room found hardest; sort, count, and open the next lecture with it.

  9. Jigsaw: expert groups, then home groupsA jigsaw, first used by Elliot Aronson's team in 1971, splits a task into parts and makes every student responsible for teaching one. It suits a case study, a reading with several sections, or a problem with several sides. Expert groups.InteractiveHands-on
    Read this step

    A jigsaw, first used by Elliot Aronson's team in 1971, splits a task into parts and makes every student responsible for teaching one. It suits a case study, a reading with several sections, or a problem with several sides.

    1. Expert groups. Each student gets one part (one section of the case, one perspective, one data set) and works on it with others who have the same part. In a big hall, split each part's students into tables of four to six.
    2. Home groups. Students regroup so that each new group has one expert per part. Each expert teaches their part; together the group solves the whole task.

    It works because nobody can sit back: the home group is missing a piece without you. In a fixed-seat hall, use rows. Students with the same part sit in the same rows for the expert phase, then turn to the row behind for the home phase.

    Try it: switch between the two phases and watch the groups re-form. Then set your own class size and the number of parts, and read the numbers.

    Interactive · Jigsaw: from expert groups to home groups — try it in the lesson

    When the class size doesn't divide evenly, the leftover students join home groups as a second expert on their part; the "+" in the numbers shows how many. Give the expert phase a written product (three points to teach, one example), and give the home group a task that needs every part to finish.

    Takeaway: in a jigsaw every student studies one part with other experts, then teaches it in a group that needs every part.

  10. Budget the minutes and the groups in a big hallA large-class activity fails most often on arithmetic: too many groups to hear from, or more minutes than the lecture has. Work out each one, then check. A hint costs nothing.Practice · 7 exercises
    Read this step

    A large-class activity fails most often on arithmetic: too many groups to hear from, or more minutes than the lecture has. Work out each one, then check. A hint costs nothing.

    200 students do a think-pair-share in pairs. How many pairs are there?

    180 students work in groups of 4. How many groups are there?

    A jigsaw with 4 parts in a hall of 180 students. How many students study each part in the expert phase?

    A 50-minute session has three mini-lectures of 12, 10 and 9 minutes. How many minutes are left for activities?

    One ConcepTest takes 2 minutes to vote, 3 minutes to discuss, 1 minute to vote again and 2 minutes to explain. How many minutes do three ConcepTests take?

    After a think-pair-share you hear from 3 pairs, 1.5 minutes each. How many minutes does the share-out take?

    220 students hand in a muddiest point, and 40% of them name the same topic. How many students is that?

Comments

You’ll sign in with Google before it’s posted.Comments are public — don’t name your students.
0 / 1,500

No comments yet. Be the first to say how it went.

Using it

Workshopy shares this lesson under CC BY 4.0. Anyone may use and change it, with credit to you. Anyone can learn it here, free. A copy in your workspace is yours to change and run live; your students never need an account.

Versions

  1. 1

    Version 1Current

    · First published

Copies are made from the current version. A copy you already have doesn’t change.

More from Workshopy

All 78 lessons
All 7 Teacher training lessons